What I love about this exchange is how fully it recapitulates so many of my experiences talking to A-plussers.
Me: I am skeptical about some of your claims.
Them: What, you doubt that [given form of bigotry] is real?
Me: No, just this one hyperbolic claim that you made, right here.
Wow, just wow. This right here is why some skeptics doubt whether plussers are a plus to our movement.